Zaburzenie reaktywnego przywiązania
Patofizjologia i mechanizm

Zaburzenie reaktywnego przywiązania (RAD) jest klasyfikowane w DSM-5 jako zaburzenie związane z traumą i stresem we wczesnym dzieciństwie, wynikające z patologicznej opieki, zaniedbania i nadużyć. Charakteryzuje się zaburzeniami w tworzeniu emocjonalnych więzi, brakiem zdolności do poszukiwania i akceptacji bliskości oraz nieadekwatnymi reakcjami na kontakt fizyczny i emocjonalny. Wyróżnia się dwa typy RAD: zahamowany (inhibited), z wycofaniem społecznym i brakiem reakcji na komfort, oraz niezahamowany (disinhibited), z niedyskryminacyjną towarzyskością i nadmierną zażyłością z obcymi. Etiologia RAD wiąże się z instytucjonalizacją, zaniedbaniem, nadużyciami, separacją od rodziców oraz częstymi zmianami opiekunów, co prowadzi do zaburzeń regulacji emocji i rozwoju neurobiologicznego, w tym zmian w ciele modzelowatym, istocie białej i szarej mózgu. Współwystępują często ADHD (52%), PTSD (19%) oraz zaburzenia ze spektrum autyzmu (14%).

Definicja i klasyfikacja zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania

Zaburzenie reaktywnego przywiązania (ang. Reactive Attachment Disorder, RAD) jest klasyfikowane w DSM-5 jako zaburzenie związane z traumą i stresem występujące we wczesnym dzieciństwie, spowodowane zaniedbaniem społecznym i niewłaściwym traktowaniem. Dotknięte nim dzieci mają trudności w tworzeniu emocjonalnych więzi z innymi, wykazują zmniejszoną zdolność do doświadczania pozytywnych emocji, nie potrafią szukać ani akceptować fizycznej lub emocjonalnej bliskości oraz mogą reagować gwałtownie, gdy są trzymane, przytulane lub pocieszane.12

Kardynalną cechą RAD jest zaburzony i nieodpowiedni dla rozwoju sposób nawiązywania relacji społecznych, wynikający z uporczywego zaniedbania lub nadużyć ze strony opiekuna dziecka. Dzieci dotknięte tym zaburzeniem rzadko lub minimalnie zwracają się preferencyjnie do figury przywiązania w poszukiwaniu komfortu, wsparcia, ochrony i opieki.34

Podtypy zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania

Wyróżnia się dwa główne typy zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania:

  • Typ zahamowany (inhibited) – charakteryzuje się wycofaniem społecznym i odbiegającym od normy zachowaniem przywiązaniowym z niezdolnością do poszukiwania i reagowania na komfort. Jest to zaburzenie braku przywiązania związane z utratą głównej figury przywiązania i brakiem możliwości nawiązania przez niemowlę nowego przywiązania do głównego opiekuna.56
  • Typ niezahamowany (disinhibited) – charakteryzuje się uczestnictwem w rozproszonych przywiązaniach, niedyskryminacyjną towarzyskością i nadmierną zażyłością z obcymi. Dziecko wielokrotnie straciło figury przywiązania lub miało wielu opiekunów i nigdy nie miało szansy na rozwinięcie ciągłego i spójnego przywiązania do co najmniej jednego opiekuna.78

Patogeneza zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania

Geneza zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania jest związana z traumatycznymi doświadczeniami, w szczególności z ciężkim zaniedbaniem emocjonalnym, często spotykanym w środowiskach instytucjonalnych, takich jak przepełnione sierocińce, opieka zastępcza lub w domach z rodzicami chorymi psychicznie lub fizycznie. Z czasem niemowlęta, które nie rozwijają przewidywalnej, opiekuńczej więzi z zaufanym opiekunem i nie otrzymują odpowiedniej interakcji emocjonalnej oraz stymulacji umysłowej, przestają podejmować próby angażowania innych i zwracają się do wewnątrz, przestając szukać pocieszenia w sytuacji zranienia, unikając fizycznej i emocjonalnej bliskości, i ostatecznie stają się emocjonalnie wydrążone.910

Rola wczesnych doświadczeń i patologicznej opieki

Wspólnym czynnikiem przyczynowym zaburzenia jest wczesna patologiczna opieka, co oznacza, że możliwości dziecka do selektywnego przywiązania zostały poważnie ograniczone. Konkretne elementy patologicznej opieki i ich wpływ na początek i różnicowanie zaburzenia nie są dobrze zrozumiane.1112

Przyczyny rozwoju RAD obejmują:

  • Instytucjonalizację – pobyt w placówkach opiekuńczych, sierocińcach
  • Zaniedbanie – w tym brak odpowiedzi na potrzeby emocjonalne dziecka
  • Nadużycia – fizyczne, emocjonalne lub psychologiczne
  • Separację od rodziców
  • Częste zmiany opiekunów – uniemożliwiające utworzenie stabilnych więzi
  • Brak responsywności opiekuna na komunikacyjne wysiłki dziecka1314

Badania wykazały, że nadużycia zakłócają zdolność dziecka do regulowania swoich emocji. Sugeruje się również, że typy temperamentu lub konstytucyjne reakcje na środowisko mogą sprawić, że niektóre osoby są podatne na stres wynikający z nieprzewidywalnych lub wrogich relacji z opiekunami w pierwszych latach życia.15

Mechanizm rozwoju zaburzenia

W dyskusji na temat neurobiologicznych podstaw przywiązania i objawów traumy w siedmioletnim badaniu bliźniąt zasugerowano, że źródła różnych form psychopatologii, w tym RAD, zaburzenia osobowości typu borderline (BPD) i zespołu stresu pourazowego (PTSD), można znaleźć w zaburzeniach regulacji afektu. Zagrożony jest później rozwój samoregulacji wyższego rzędu, a kształtowanie się modeli wewnętrznych jest zaburzone.16

Od II wojny światowej lekarze, psycholodzy i teoretycy przywiązania dokumentowali wpływ zaniedbania społecznego na rozwój fizyczny i emocjonalny. Eksperymenty przeprowadzone w latach 40. i 50. XX wieku wykazały, że deprywacja macierzyńska miała głęboki wpływ na wzrost niemowląt, rozwój motoryczny, interakcje społeczne i zachowanie.1718

W filmie „Psychogenic Diseases in Infancy” (Spitz, 1952) niemowlęta odbiegały od normalnego, oczekiwanego przebiegu rozwoju i stawały się „niedostępne, płaczliwe i krzyczące” w ciągu pierwszych 2 miesięcy deprywacji macierzyńskiej. W miarę kontynuowania deprywacji wyraz twarzy stawał się sztywny, a następnie płaski; rozwój motoryczny ulegał regresji, a do piątego miesiąca niemowlęta były „letargiczne”, niezdolne do „siedzenia, stania, chodzenia lub mówienia”, cierpiały na zaburzenia wzrostu, rozwijały „atypowe, dziwaczne ruchy palców” i nie poszukiwały już ani nie reagowały na interakcje społeczne; 37,3% niemowląt zmarło w ciągu 2 lat.19

Neurobiologiczne podstawy zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania

Implikacje neurobiologiczne RAD są nadal bardzo słabo zbadane, ale niektóre badania sugerują, że dzieci z RAD są bardziej narażone na liczne współchorobowości, takie jak zaburzenie deficytu uwagi z hiperaktywnością (ADHD; 52%), zaburzenie stresowe pourazowe (PTSD; 19%) i zaburzenia ze spektrum autyzmu (14%).20

Zmiany strukturalne i funkcjonalne w mózgu

Zauważono, że wczesne doświadczenia z dzieciństwa mogą wpływać na strukturę neuronów, a także na komunikację między nimi. Jeśli zostaną zmienione z powodu patologii choroby, może to mieć zdumiewający wpływ na rozwój różnych regionów mózgu, szczególnie połączeń między regionami emocjonalnymi a różnymi korami, które pomagają w kształtowaniu osobowości i innych wyższych funkcji.21

Badanie Newmana i wsp. wykazało, że wczesne zakłócenia w systemie przywiązania mogą prowadzić do niekorzystnego rozwoju przywiązania, gdy osoba osiągnie dorosłość. Takie konsekwencje są niepokojące, ponieważ może to prowadzić do rozwoju innych zaburzeń psychicznych. Co ciekawe, Newman i wsp. wspomnieli, że dzieci, które miały historię złego traktowania we wczesnym dzieciństwie, wykazywały zmniejszoną objętość wewnątrzczaszkową i zmniejszony rozmiar ciała modzelowatego.22

Makita i wsp. w 2020 roku badali zmiany mózgowe u dzieci ze zdiagnozowanym RAD i stwierdzili znaczące zmiany w strukturze mózgu u tych pacjentów. To badanie szczególnie opisywało zmiany w traktach istoty białej, zwłaszcza w obrębie ciała modzelowatego i obwodów korowo-limbicznych. Zgłoszono również, że RAD było bezpośrednio związane ze zmniejszeniem objętości istoty szarej, szczególnie w korze wzrokowej, oraz ze zmianą funkcji brzusznego prążkowia.23

Rola hormonów i neurotransmiterów

Chambers w 2017 roku badał interakcję między rozwijającym się podwzgórzem a poziomami kortyzolu u rozwijających się niemowląt. Wykazano, że oksytocyna, hormon produkowany podczas więzi macierzyńskiej z dzieckiem, zmniejsza poziom kortyzolu, szczególnie w interakcjach społecznych.24

Nadużycia w dzieciństwie zostały skorelowane z trudnościami w pamięci roboczej i funkcjach wykonawczych, podczas gdy poważne zaniedbanie jest związane z niedorozwojem lewej półkuli mózgowej i hipokampa.25

U dzieci z psychiatryczną depresją poziomy kortyzolu są podwyższone, występują nieefektywności w funkcjonowaniu serotoniny i innych neurotransmiterów oraz zmniejszona produkcja hormonu wzrostu.26

Teoria przywiązania a zaburzenie reaktywnego przywiązania

Aktualne rozumienie zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania obejmuje teorię przywiązania, która zakłada, że niemowlęta tworzą przywiązania do swoich głównych opiekunów, a jakość tych przywiązań może wpływać na koncepcję relacji międzyludzkich dziecka w miarę dorastania.27

Hipoteza mediacji i teoria przywiązania

Aktualna hipoteza mediacji ma na celu omówienie związku między brakiem emocjonalnej opieki a rozwojem RAD. Sprzeczne dowody dotyczące tej hipotezy dodatkowo podkreślają wieloczynnikową jakość RAD.28

Teoria przywiązania, opisana w artykule opublikowanym przez Bosmansa i wsp. w 2020 roku, badała korelację między przywiązaniem a bezpieczeństwem, które dziecko może mieć ze swoim opiekunem, i sugerowała, że poprzez zwiększenie przywiązania dziecko może czuć się bezpieczniej i odwrotnie.29

W 2019 roku Kobak i Bosman badali związek między wrodzonym systemem przywiązania u dzieci, który wymaga pielęgnacji, szczególnie w czasach stresu. Kluczowym punktem do zauważenia w tej teorii jest to, że raz nauczony, jest on trwałym elementem dla dziecka. Ta teoria jest kluczowa do wdrożenia w potencjalnej genezie RAD, ponieważ nie tylko uwzględnia znaczenie pozytywnych i negatywnych wydarzeń w życiu, które mogą modyfikować wrodzony system przywiązania.30

Wpływ wiedzy o Secure Base Script na zaburzenie reaktywnego przywiązania

Obecne badanie skupiło się na roli reprezentacji przywiązania i przetestowało, czy te reprezentacje pośredniczą czy moderują związek między objawami RAD a problemami z zachowaniem prospołecznym. Wyniki nie poparły hipotezy mediacji, ale znaleziono dowody na hipotezę moderacji. Wiedza o Secure Base Script (SBS) osłabiła negatywny związek między objawami zaburzenia przywiązania a zachowaniem prospołecznym.3132

Aktualna hipoteza mediacji podąża za teorią psychiatryczną, która zakłada unikalny związek między objawami RAD a niebezpiecznym przywiązaniem. Terminologia zaburzenia przywiązania wydaje się sugerować, że niebezpieczne reprezentacje przywiązania (tzn. brak wiedzy SBS) są głównym i najbardziej specyficznym problemem, gdy dzieci wykazują objawy RAD.33

Teoria przewiduje, że wszystkie dzieci z objawami RAD wykazują zerwane zaufanie do dostępności ich głównych opiekunów, odzwierciedlone w niebezpiecznych reprezentacjach przywiązania. Z kolei teoria przywiązania zakłada, że niebezpieczne reprezentacje przywiązania są związane ze zmniejszonym zachowaniem prospołecznym dzieci.34

Badania i koncepcje naukowe dotyczące zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania

Otworzenie sierocińców w Europie Wschodniej po zakończeniu zimnej wojny na początku lat 90. XX wieku stworzyło możliwości badania niemowląt i małych dzieci wychowywanych w bardzo ubogich warunkach. Takie badania poszerzyły zrozumienie występowania, przyczyn, mechanizmu i oceny zaburzeń przywiązania i doprowadziły do wysiłków od końca lat 90. XX wieku w celu opracowania programów leczenia i profilaktyki oraz lepszych metod oceny.35

Krytyka i kontrowersje wokół diagnozy RAD

Ze względu na względną nowość zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania jako akceptowanej diagnozy klinicznej, istnieje szereg krytyk obecnej konceptualizacji RAD. Patologiczna opieka jest opisana jako etiologia RAD, przy niewielkiej uwadze poświęconej biologicznej predyspozycji do rozwoju zaburzenia.36

Niektórzy psycholodzy rozwojowi sugerują, że RAD najlepiej konceptualizować jako zaburzenie rozwojowe lub zespół złego traktowania. Ponadto, ustalenia w literaturze dotyczącej złego traktowania dzieci sugerują, że chociaż maltretowane dzieci często rozwijają niepewne lub zdezorganizowane wzorce relacyjne, aby radzić sobie z nieregularną opieką, jaką otrzymują, nie jest to koniecznie równoznaczne z zaburzonym przywiązaniem.37

Kilku autorów kwestionuje, czy RAD jest ważną kategorią diagnostyczną, cytując nakładanie się objawów z całościowymi zaburzeniami rozwojowymi i innymi zaburzeniami, niespójne połączenie z teorią przywiązania oraz brak empirycznej walidacji.38

Stabilność objawów i długotrwałe efekty

Niewiele informacji jest dostępnych na temat stabilności objawów RAD. Jedno badanie sugeruje, że objawy RAD stabilizują się między 22 a 54 miesiącem życia i trwają dłużej u dzieci, które były instytucjonalizowane przez dłuższy czas.39

Zachowania niedyskryminacyjne związane z tym zaburzeniem mają tendencję do utrzymywania się w okresie dojrzewania. Nadmierna przyjazność i poszukiwanie uwagi były obserwowane u wcześniej instytucjonalizowanych dzieci w wieku od 4 do 8 lat.40

Zaburzenia przywiązania często współistnieją z innymi zaburzeniami związanymi z wczesną deprywacją. W przypadku RAD mogą to być depresja, problemy w relacjach społecznych, PTSD oraz opóźnienia poznawcze i językowe.41

Genetyczne i temperamentalne czynniki wpływające na rozwój RAD

Chociaż nie przeprowadzono badań na temat wpływu temperamentu na rozwój RAD, obecna wiedza sugeruje, że temperament może odgrywać ważną rolę w etiologii RAD, a jego wpływ powinien być dalej badany.42

Pewne podatności genetyczne związane z czynnikiem neurotroficznym pochodzenia mózgowego i genami transportera serotoniny, w połączeniu z historią zaniedbania/opieki, mogą skutkować bardziej znaczącymi trudnościami z dysinhibicją społeczną.43

Zaburzenia przywiązania powstają prawie wyłącznie tam, gdzie wystąpiła patologiczna opieka. Jednak patologiczna opieka jest koniecznym, ale niewystarczającym warunkiem dla zaburzenia przywiązania. Nie wszystkie dzieci, które doświadczają takich warunków, rozwijają RAD lub DSED; w rzeczywistości większość tego nie robi.44

Dowody sugerują, że czynniki genetyczne nie odgrywają roli, a zaburzenia przywiązania powstają przede wszystkim w wyniku środowiska opiekuńczego, na które dziecko jest narażone.45

Współwystępujące zaburzenia i ich wpływ na obraz kliniczny

Połączone RAD i DSED często współwystępuje zarówno z objawami i zaburzeniami emocjonalnymi (takimi jak depresja i lęk), jak i objawami i zaburzeniami behawioralnymi (takimi jak zaburzenie opozycyjno-buntownicze (ODD), zaburzenie zachowania (CD) lub zaburzenie deficytu uwagi z hiperaktywnością (ADHD)).46

Ustalenie, że zarówno problemy emocjonalne, jak i behawioralne mogą współwystępować z RAD i być związane z obciążeniem objawami RAD w okresie dojrzewania, jest zgodne z wcześniejszymi ustaleniami wśród dzieci w wieku szkolnym i wczesnych nastolatków.47

Wskaźniki występowania ADHD i CD/ODD u nastolatków z DSED przypominają ustalenia u dzieci w wieku przedszkolnym i szkolnym z oznakami DSED, w tym dzieci wychowywanych w domu i adoptowanych po pobycie w instytucjach.48

Ogólne ustalenie, że DSED w okresie dojrzewania jest związane zarówno z problemami emocjonalnymi, jak i behawioralnymi, jest również zgodne z niektórymi wynikami badań młodszych dzieci.49

Zaburzenie reaktywne przywiązania zwiększa ryzyko lęku, depresji, nadaktywności i zmniejsza tolerancję na frustrację.50

Identyfikacja i diagnostyka zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania

Zaburzenia przywiązania są trudne do zdiagnozowania. Wytyczne praktyki wzywają do wielokrotnych obserwacji dziecka wchodzącego w interakcje z głównymi opiekunami, a także historii interakcji dziecka z tymi opiekunami.51

Zaburzenie reaktywne przywiązania może rozwinąć się, gdy dziecko nie ma możliwości tworzenia stabilnych więzi z powodu wcześniejszego zaniedbania, nadużycia lub traumy. Eksperci sugerują, że trauma rozwija się u instytucjonalizowanych dzieci, gdy są oddzielone od matek biologicznych. Ta niespójna i nieszczera relacja z dorosłymi tworzy nieufność i zmusza niemowlę do rozpoczęcia samodzielnej samoregulacji.52

Implikacje dla zdrowia psychicznego w późniejszym życiu

Zgodnie z American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, ponieważ dzieci, które doświadczają takiego zaniedbania, nie mają możliwości tworzenia więzi z opiekunami we wczesnym rozwoju, nauczyły się nie szukać żadnego komfortu ani odpowiedzi od opiekunów.53

Chociaż objawy zaburzenia reaktywnego przywiązania zwykle ustępują, gdy dzieci są usuwane ze środowisk deprywacyjnych, mniej jasne jest, czy RAD we wczesnym dzieciństwie predysponuje dziecko do późniejszych trudności interpersonalnych, nawet po tym, jak zaburzenie nie jest już wykrywalne.54

Zaburzenie reaktywne przywiązania zwykle zaczyna się przed 5 rokiem życia i utrzymuje się w czasie. Wynika z braku podstawowego przywiązania emocjonalnego i/lub patologicznych warunków opieki, szczególnie w pierwszych latach dzieciństwa.55

Zgłoszono, że brak leczenia RAD w dzieciństwie może być związany z dorosłymi, u których zdiagnozowano zaburzenia socjopatyczne, narcystyczne, aspołeczne lub graniczne.56

Zaburzenie reaktywnego przywiązania u dorosłych

Chociaż RAD nie jest zwykle diagnozowane u dorosłych, jego efekty mogą trwać w dorosłości, prowadząc do wyzwań w tworzeniu zdrowych relacji i zarządzaniu emocjami.5758

Fundamentalny brak zaufania do innych może trwać w dorosłości. Osoby takie mogą być stale podejrzliwe co do intencji innych, co utrudnia im tworzenie stabilnych relacji. Nierozwiązane uczucia z dzieciństwa mogą przejawiać się jako gniew i agresja lub potrzeba kontrolowania sytuacji i ludzi wokół nich.59

Dorośli, którzy jako dzieci mieli RAD, mogą być również bardziej podatni na stany takie jak depresja, zaburzenia lękowe lub zaburzenia osobowości.6061

Korelację między zaburzeniem reaktywnego przywiązania (RAD) w dzieciństwie a wzorcami nadużywania substancji w dorosłości można zrozumieć przez pryzmat teorii przywiązania i długoterminowego wpływu wczesnej traumy relacyjnej.62

Kolejne rozdziały

Zapraszamy do dalszego czytania naszego leksykonu.

Wybierz kolejny rozdział z menu poniżej, aby otworzyć nową podstronę kompedium wiedzy i uzyskać szczegółowe informację o leku, substancji lub chorobie.

  1. 09.04.2026
  2. www.leksykon.com.pl

Materiały źródłowe

  • #1 Reactive Attachment Disorder – StatPearls – NCBI BookshelfTwitterFacebookLinkedInGitHubNCBI Insights BlogTwitterFacebookYoutube
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537155/
    The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual 5th Edition (DSM-5) classifies reactive attachment disorder as a trauma- and stressor-related condition of early childhood caused by social neglect and maltreatment. Affected children have difficulty forming emotional attachments to others, show a decreased ability to experience positive emotion, cannot seek or accept physical or emotional closeness, and may react violently when held, cuddled, or comforted. […] The genesis of reactive attachment disorder is encompassed under the designation of traumatic experience; specifically, the severe emotional neglect commonly found in institutional settings, such as overcrowded orphanages, foster care, or in homes with mentally or physically ill parents. Over time, infants who do not develop a predictable, nurturing bond with a trusted caregiver, do not receive adequate emotional interaction and mental stimulation halt their attempts to engage others and turn inward, ceasing to seek comfort when hurt, avoiding physical and emotional closeness, and eventually become emotionally bereft.
  • #2 Reactive attachment disorder – Symptoms & causes – Mayo Clinic
    https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/reactive-attachment-disorder/symptoms-causes/syc-20352939
    Reactive attachment disorder is a rare but serious condition in which an infant or young child doesn’t establish healthy attachments with parents or caregivers. Reactive attachment disorder may develop if the child’s basic needs for comfort, affection and nurturing aren’t met and loving, caring, stable attachments with others are not established. […] It’s not clear why some babies and children develop reactive attachment disorder and others don’t. Various theories about reactive attachment disorder and its causes exist, and more research is needed to develop a better understanding and improve diagnosis and treatment options. […] Without proper treatment, reactive attachment disorder can continue for several years and may have lifelong consequences. These can include problems with relationships, social interactions, mental and physical health, behavior, intellectual development, and substance abuse.
  • #3 Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) – PsychDB
    https://www.psychdb.com/child/attachment/reactive-attachment-disorder
    Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) is a disorder of infancy and early childhood, characterized by a pattern of significant disturbance and developmentally inappropriate attachment behaviors. The infant or child will rarely or minimally turn preferentially to an attachment figure for comfort, support, protection, and/or nurturance. At its core, there is an absent or severely underdeveloped attachment between the child and the caregiving adult(s). […] The care in Criterion C is presumed to be responsible for the disturbed behaviour in Criterion A (e.g. – the disturbances in Criterion A began following the lack of adequate care in Criterion C). […] Reactive attachment disorder is specified as severe when a child exhibits all symptoms of the disorder, with each symptom manifesting at relatively high levels. […] Children with reactive attachment disorder are believed to actually have the capacity to form selective attachments, but due to limited opportunities during early childhood development, they fail to develop these selective attachments.
  • #4 Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) | EBSCO Research Starters
    https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/psychology/reactive-attachment-disorder-rad
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is a variant of a general condition of impoverished psychosocial and physical development found in infants and children deprived of appropriate caretaking. The symptoms of RAD are believed to remit in an improved environment with a responsive caregiver. […] The fifth edition, DSM-5 (2013), describes the cardinal feature of RAD as disturbed and developmentally inappropriate social relations produced by persistent neglect or abuse on the part of the child’s caregiver. […] Associated features of RAD include the physical signs of an impoverished rearing environment, such as developmental delays, feeding disorders, growth delays (that is, failure to thrive), physical abuse, and malnutrition. […] Although adverse environmental conditions and pathogenic relationships in childhood may increase the risk for later antisocial behavior, no direct etiological links have been established between these behaviors and the characteristics of RAD.
  • #5 Reactive Attachment Disorder | Psychlinks Forum — Archive Only (2004-2022)
    https://forum.psychlinks.ca/threads/reactive-attachment-disorder.3820/
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD), as defined by the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), requires etiologic factors, such as gross deprivation of care or successive multiple caregivers, for diagnosis. […] In inhibited RAD, the child does not initiate and respond to social interactions in a developmentally appropriate manner. It is a disorder of nonattachment and is related to the loss of the primary attachment figure and the lack of opportunity for the infant to establish a new attachment with a primary caregiver. […] Also, a nonattachment disorder may develop because the baby never had the opportunity to develop at least one attachment with a reliable caregiver who was continuously present in the baby’s life.
  • #6 Reactive Attachment Disorder Help Factsheet | Behaviour Help
    https://behaviourhelp.com/a-z-conditions-disorders/reactive-attachment-disorder
    There are two main types of reactive attachment disorder. These are: Inhibited reactive attachment disorder – this is when the affected child shows signs of inexplicable signs of being wary, watchful and overly vigilant. In most cases, such affected children may be aware or sensitive about what is going on around them but may not show any signs of interest in their environment or what is going on around them. Disinhibited reactive attachment disorder – this type of RAD exhibits itself when the affected child is overly and indiscriminately friendly to strangers, socializing freely with strangers without the normal child withdrawal to safety when around strangers and/or showing no need to be close to a parent or caregiver for safety. […] Some of the generally common signs and symptoms of reactive attachment disorder include: Those affected would show signs of chronic patterns of being emotionally withdrawn, keeping to themselves, looking sad, being afraid or showing fear or unfounded or inexplicable irritability. Those affected would appear sad and lethargic and fail to smile without a clear cause. Some may not seek comfort even when in distress or may not even respond to comfort when it is offered. Not engaging in social interactions despite being in social environments with others. Failing to seek support or any form of assistance when one needs it. Failing to reach out even when being picked up. Showing no interest in playing fun games or other interactive games with others or themselves. An affected child or person may not show or express conscience emotions such as regret, remorse or even guilt. Affected children or persons may avoid physical touch from parents or caregivers. Affected children or persons may avoid making eye contact with others.
  • #7 Reactive Attachment Disorder | Psychlinks Forum — Archive Only (2004-2022)
    https://forum.psychlinks.ca/threads/reactive-attachment-disorder.3820/
    In disinhibited RAD, the child participates in diffuse attachments, indiscriminate sociability, and excessive familiarity with strangers. The child has repeatedly lost attachment figures or has had multiple caregivers and has never had the chance to develop a continuous and consistent attachment to at least one caregiver. […] Disruption of one attachment relationship after another causes the infant to renounce attachments. […] The usual anxiety and concern with strangers is not present, and the infant or child superficially accepts anyone as a caregiver (as though people were interchangeable) and acts as if the relationship had been intimate and life-long. […] If caregivers are not reliably or consistently present or if they respond in an unpredictable and uncertain way, babies are not able to establish a pattern of confident expectation. One result is insecure attachment, or a less than optimal internal sense of confidence and trust in others, beginning with caregivers.
  • #8 Reactive Attachment Disorder and Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder | Abnormal Psychology
    https://courses.lumenlearning.com/wm-abnormalpsych/chapter/reactive-attachment-disorder-and-disinhibited-social-engagement-disorder/
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is characterized by markedly disturbed and developmentally inappropriate ways of relating socially in most contexts. […] RAD and DSED arise from a failure to form normal attachments to primary caregivers in early childhood. Such a failure could result from severe early experiences of neglect, abuse, abrupt separation from caregivers between the ages of six months and three years, frequent changes of caregivers, or a lack of caregiver responsiveness to a child’s communicative efforts. […] Although increasing numbers of childhood mental health problems are being attributed to genetic defects, reactive attachment disorder is by definition based on a problematic history of care and social relationships. […] While similar abnormal parenting may produce the two distinct forms of the disorder, inhibited (RAD) and disinhibited (DSED), studies show that the abuse and neglect was far more prominent and severe in the cases of disinhibited social engagement disorder.
  • #9 Reactive Attachment Disorder – StatPearls – NCBI BookshelfTwitterFacebookLinkedInGitHubNCBI Insights BlogTwitterFacebookYoutube
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537155/
    The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual 5th Edition (DSM-5) classifies reactive attachment disorder as a trauma- and stressor-related condition of early childhood caused by social neglect and maltreatment. Affected children have difficulty forming emotional attachments to others, show a decreased ability to experience positive emotion, cannot seek or accept physical or emotional closeness, and may react violently when held, cuddled, or comforted. […] The genesis of reactive attachment disorder is encompassed under the designation of traumatic experience; specifically, the severe emotional neglect commonly found in institutional settings, such as overcrowded orphanages, foster care, or in homes with mentally or physically ill parents. Over time, infants who do not develop a predictable, nurturing bond with a trusted caregiver, do not receive adequate emotional interaction and mental stimulation halt their attempts to engage others and turn inward, ceasing to seek comfort when hurt, avoiding physical and emotional closeness, and eventually become emotionally bereft.
  • #10 Reactive Attachment Disorder | Treatment & Management | Point of Care
    https://www.statpearls.com/point-of-care/19406
    The genesis of reactive attachment disorder is encompassed under the designation of traumatic experience; specifically, the severe emotional neglect commonly found in institutional settings, such as overcrowded orphanages, foster care, or in homes with mentally or physically ill parents. […] Over time, infants who do not develop a predictable, nurturing bond with a trusted caregiver, do not receive adequate emotional interaction and mental stimulation halt their attempts to engage others and turn inward, ceasing to seek comfort when hurt, avoiding physical and emotional closeness, and eventually become emotionally bereft. […] The absence of adequate nurturing results in poor language acquisition, impaired cognitive development, and contributes to behavioral dysfunction. […] Since WWII, physicians, psychologists, and attachment theorists have documented the impact of social neglect on physical and emotional development.
  • #11 Caring for Kids New to Canada – Attachment Disorders
    https://kidsnewtocanada.ca/mental-health/attachment-disorders
    The DSM-V recognizes 2 distinct forms of attachment disorder: reactive attachment disorder and disinhibited social engagement disorder. The first involves the inability to attach to a preferred caregiver, and the second involves indiscriminate sociability and disinhibited attachment behaviours. […] The common causal factor for both disorders is early pathogenic care, meaning a child’s opportunities for selective attachment have been seriously constricted. […] Both reactive attachment disorder of infancy and early childhood and disinhibited social engagement disorder are trauma- and stress-related disturbances linked to social neglect so extreme as to impair a child’s opportunities to form attachments to a preferred caregiver (or caregivers). Specific elements of pathogenic care and how they affect onset and differentiation of disorder are not well understood.
  • #12 Caring for Kids New to Canada – Attachment Disorders
    https://kidsnewtocanada.ca/mental-health/attachment-disorders
    Reactive attachment disorder happens when no figure is found to attach to in early life. […] The essential elements of pathogenic care and their association with the onset and differentiation of disorder are not well understood. However, we know that pathogenic care is a necessary but insufficient condition for attachment disorder. Not all children who experience such conditions develop RAD or DSED; indeed, most do not. […] Environmental considerations and what differentiates low quality care from pathogenic care are always difficult to ascertain or study in very young children. However, known risk factors include: length of time in institutional care, adoption (in institution-reared children), parental maltreatment, having a mother who has been hospitalized for psychiatric reasons, or extremely disrupted mother/child communication (in home-reared children).
  • #13 Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) – Attachment and Trauma Network
    https://www.attachmenttraumanetwork.org/reactive-attachment-disorder-rad/
    Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) is the diagnosis associated with attachment impairment. […] The causes of RAD can be traced back to the child’s history, specifically instances of severe neglect or abuse that hinder the development of secure attachments with caregivers. […] Reactive Attachment Disorder is thought to occur when a child is unable to form a secure bond with a parent or primary caregiver due to emotional deprivation. This can be a result of: Institutionalization, Neglect, Abuse, Separation from parents. […] Research has indicated that there is an increased likelihood of Reactive Attachment Disorder in children who have experienced maltreatment. […] Neglect and abuse have a significant impact on the development of Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD). Children who experience severe neglect or abuse are at a heightened risk of developing Reactive Attachment Disorder.
  • #14 Reactive attachment disorder – Wikipedia
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_attachment_disorder
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is described in clinical literature as a severe disorder that can affect children, although these issues do occasionally persist into adulthood. […] RAD arises from a failure to form normal attachments to primary caregivers in early childhood. Such a failure could result from severe early experiences of neglect, abuse, abrupt separation from caregivers between the ages of six months and three years, frequent changes of caregivers, or a lack of caregiver responsiveness to a child’s communicative efforts. […] Children with RAD are presumed to have grossly disturbed internal working models of relationships that may lead to interpersonal and behavioral difficulties in later life. […] However, the opening of orphanages in Eastern Europe following the end of the Cold War in the early 1990s provided opportunities for research on infants and toddlers brought up in very deprived conditions. Such research broadened the understanding of the prevalence, causes, mechanism and assessment of disorders of attachment and led to efforts from the late 1990s onwards to develop treatment and prevention programs and better methods of assessment.
  • #15 Reactive Attachment Disorder and Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder | Abnormal Psychology
    https://courses.lumenlearning.com/wm-abnormalpsych/chapter/reactive-attachment-disorder-and-disinhibited-social-engagement-disorder/
    The core feature is severely inappropriate social relating by affected children. […] Research has shown that abuse disrupts a child’s ability to regulate their emotions. […] It has been suggested that types of temperament, or constitutional response to the environment, may make some individuals susceptible to the stress of unpredictable or hostile relationships with caregivers in the early years. […] In the absence of available and responsive caregivers, it appears that most children are particularly vulnerable to developing attachment disorders.
  • #16 Reactive attachment disorder – Wikipedia
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_attachment_disorder
    While similar abnormal parenting may produce the two distinct forms of the disorder, inhibited and disinhibited, studies show that abuse and neglect were far more prominent and severe in the cases of RAD, disinhibited type. […] In discussing the neurobiological basis for attachment and trauma symptoms in a seven-year twin study, it has been suggested that the roots of various forms of psychopathology, including RAD, borderline personality disorder (BPD), and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), can be found in disturbances in affect regulation. The subsequent development of higher-order self-regulation is jeopardized and the formation of internal models is affected.
  • #17 Reactive Attachment Disorder – StatPearls – NCBI BookshelfTwitterFacebookLinkedInGitHubNCBI Insights BlogTwitterFacebookYoutube
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537155/
    Since WWII, physicians, psychologists, and attachment theorists have documented the impact of social neglect on physical and emotional development. Experiments completed in the 1940s and 1950s found that maternal deprivation had a profound effect on infant growth, motor development, social interaction, and behavior. In the film Psychogenic Diseases in Infancy (Spitz, 1952), infants deviated from the normal, expected course of development and became “unapproachable, weepy and screaming” within the first 2 months of maternal deprivation. As the deprivation continued, facial expressions became rigid and then flat; motor development regressed, and by the fifth month, infants were “lethargic,” unable to “sit, stand, walk, or talk,” suffered from growth abnormalities, developed “atypical, bizarre finger movements,” and no longer sought or responded to social interaction; 37.3% of the infants died within 2 years. These early experiments became the foundation for Attachment Theory and outlined the constellation of symptoms of what the DSM, Third Edition (DSM-III) would later call reactive attachment disorder.
  • #18 Reactive Attachment Disorder | Treatment & Management | Point of Care
    https://www.statpearls.com/point-of-care/19406
    Experiments completed in the 1940s and 1950s found that maternal deprivation had a profound effect on infant growth, motor development, social interaction, and behavior. […] These early experiments became the foundation for Attachment Theory and outlined the constellation of symptoms of what the DSM, Third Edition (DSMIII) would later call reactive attachment disorder. […] Abuse in childhood has been correlated with difficulties in working memory and executive functioning, while severe neglect is associated with underdevelopment of the left cerebral hemisphere and the hippocampus. […] Social skills are below what would be expected of either their chronological age or developmental level. […] RAD increases the risk of anxiety, depression, hyperactivity, and reduces frustration tolerance.
  • #19 Reactive Attachment Disorder – StatPearls – NCBI BookshelfTwitterFacebookLinkedInGitHubNCBI Insights BlogTwitterFacebookYoutube
    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537155/
    Since WWII, physicians, psychologists, and attachment theorists have documented the impact of social neglect on physical and emotional development. Experiments completed in the 1940s and 1950s found that maternal deprivation had a profound effect on infant growth, motor development, social interaction, and behavior. In the film Psychogenic Diseases in Infancy (Spitz, 1952), infants deviated from the normal, expected course of development and became “unapproachable, weepy and screaming” within the first 2 months of maternal deprivation. As the deprivation continued, facial expressions became rigid and then flat; motor development regressed, and by the fifth month, infants were “lethargic,” unable to “sit, stand, walk, or talk,” suffered from growth abnormalities, developed “atypical, bizarre finger movements,” and no longer sought or responded to social interaction; 37.3% of the infants died within 2 years. These early experiments became the foundation for Attachment Theory and outlined the constellation of symptoms of what the DSM, Third Edition (DSM-III) would later call reactive attachment disorder.
  • #20 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    The neurobiological implications of RAD are still very under-researched, but some studies have proposed that children with RAD are more likely to have multiple comorbidities such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD; 52%), post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD; 19%), and autism spectrum disorder (14%). […] Neurobiological changes in RAD have been seldom examined in the existing literature. While understanding the importance of the relationship of the attachment between the child and their primary caregiver, deeper comprehension of the neurobiological changes that occur due to this disorder can aid in better and more targeted treatment through both non-pharmacological and pharmacological modalities. […] It has been noted that early childhood experiences can affect the structure of neurons as well as the communication between them. If altered due to disease pathology, this can have astounding effects on the development of different regions of the brain, especially the connections between the emotional regions and the different cortices that aid in shaping one’s personality and other higher functions.
  • #21 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    The neurobiological implications of RAD are still very under-researched, but some studies have proposed that children with RAD are more likely to have multiple comorbidities such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD; 52%), post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD; 19%), and autism spectrum disorder (14%). […] Neurobiological changes in RAD have been seldom examined in the existing literature. While understanding the importance of the relationship of the attachment between the child and their primary caregiver, deeper comprehension of the neurobiological changes that occur due to this disorder can aid in better and more targeted treatment through both non-pharmacological and pharmacological modalities. […] It has been noted that early childhood experiences can affect the structure of neurons as well as the communication between them. If altered due to disease pathology, this can have astounding effects on the development of different regions of the brain, especially the connections between the emotional regions and the different cortices that aid in shaping one’s personality and other higher functions.
  • #22 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    A study by Newman et al. stated that early disruptions in the attachment system can lead to a detrimental development of attachment when a person reaches adulthood. Such ramifications are concerning as this can lead to the development of other psychiatric disorders. […] Interestingly, Newman et al. mentioned that children who have had a history of maltreatment in their early childhood showed decreased intracranial volumes and a decreased size of the corpus callosum. […] Returning to the complex interaction that is attachment, Chambers in 2017 explored the interaction between the developing hypothalamus and levels of cortisol in developing infants. It was shown that oxytocin, which is a hormone produced during maternal bonding with their child, has been shown to decrease cortisol levels, especially in social interactions.
  • #23 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    Makita et al. in 2020 explored the cerebral changes in children diagnosed with RAD and found significant changes to the structure of the brain in these patients. This study particularly described changes in the white matter tracts, especially within the corpus callosum and corticolimbic circuits a well. […] It was also reported that RAD was directly associated with a reduction in grey matter volume, especially in the visual cortex, and a change in the function of the ventral striatum. […] The etiology of RAD has been investigated to a certain extent, according to our search of existing literature. Like many psychiatric diagnoses, RAD can be presumed to be multifactorial; however, some etiologies stand out as a more likely trigger for RAD. A form of trauma has consistently been described in the pre-existing literature.
  • #24 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    A study by Newman et al. stated that early disruptions in the attachment system can lead to a detrimental development of attachment when a person reaches adulthood. Such ramifications are concerning as this can lead to the development of other psychiatric disorders. […] Interestingly, Newman et al. mentioned that children who have had a history of maltreatment in their early childhood showed decreased intracranial volumes and a decreased size of the corpus callosum. […] Returning to the complex interaction that is attachment, Chambers in 2017 explored the interaction between the developing hypothalamus and levels of cortisol in developing infants. It was shown that oxytocin, which is a hormone produced during maternal bonding with their child, has been shown to decrease cortisol levels, especially in social interactions.
  • #25 Reactive Attachment Disorder | Treatment & Management | Point of Care
    https://www.statpearls.com/point-of-care/19406
    Experiments completed in the 1940s and 1950s found that maternal deprivation had a profound effect on infant growth, motor development, social interaction, and behavior. […] These early experiments became the foundation for Attachment Theory and outlined the constellation of symptoms of what the DSM, Third Edition (DSMIII) would later call reactive attachment disorder. […] Abuse in childhood has been correlated with difficulties in working memory and executive functioning, while severe neglect is associated with underdevelopment of the left cerebral hemisphere and the hippocampus. […] Social skills are below what would be expected of either their chronological age or developmental level. […] RAD increases the risk of anxiety, depression, hyperactivity, and reduces frustration tolerance.
  • #26 Management of a Child with Reactive Attachment Disorder in the Dental Clinical Setting: A Case Report
    http://www.scielo.sa.cr/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S2215-34112020000100039
    RAD usually begins before the age of 5 years and persists over time. […] It results from a lack of basic emotional attachment and/or pathogenic care conditions, particularly during the first years of childhood. […] The disorder has also been strongly associated with early maltreatment and affects deprivation by the primary caregiver, typically through abuse, neglect, and abandonment. […] In RAD children, psychological depression leads to increased levels of cortisol, inefficiencies in the functioning of serotonin and other neurotransmitters and reduced growth-hormone production. […] The medical management of the disorder is fundamentally psychological (e.g. enhanced caregiving, promoting secure and healthy attachments, teaching of basic pragmatic skills to affected children, developing appropriate rules and realistic limits, and maintaining routines for increasing feelings of security, in a consistent and compassionate manner), and, in some cases, psychiatric with specific drugs.
  • #27 Reactive Attachment Disorder: Symptoms and Causes | BetterHelp
    https://www.betterhelp.com/mental-health/disorders-conditions/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD), a condition found in children who may have had grossly negligent care and don’t form healthy relationships with caregivers, is classified as a trauma- and stressor-based disorder in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-V), meaning it is directly caused by a traumatic or stressful event. […] Current understanding of reactive attachment disorder involves attachment theory, which posits that infants form attachments to their primary caregivers, and the quality of those attachments can impact a child’s conception of interpersonal relationships as they grow older. […] According to the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, reactive attachment disorder is caused by experiencing severe social neglect in infancy or early childhood, as described in the diagnostic criteria.
  • #28 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    The current mediation hypothesis aims to discuss the relationship between a lack of emotional nurture and the development of RAD. […] The contrasting evidence concerning this hypothesis furthermore highlights the multifactorial quality of RAD. […] The attachment theory, described in an article published by Bosmans et al. in 2020 examined a correlation between attachment and security that a child may have with their caregiver and suggested that through an increase in attachment, a child may feel more secure and vice versa. […] In 2019, Kobak and Bosman explored the connection between an innate attachment system in children that needs to be nurtured, especially during times of distress. A key point to note in this theory is that once learned, it is a permanent fixture for a child. This theory is crucial to implement in the potential genesis of RAD in our opinion as not only does it incorporate the importance of positive and negative events in life that can modify the innate attachment system.
  • #29 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    The current mediation hypothesis aims to discuss the relationship between a lack of emotional nurture and the development of RAD. […] The contrasting evidence concerning this hypothesis furthermore highlights the multifactorial quality of RAD. […] The attachment theory, described in an article published by Bosmans et al. in 2020 examined a correlation between attachment and security that a child may have with their caregiver and suggested that through an increase in attachment, a child may feel more secure and vice versa. […] In 2019, Kobak and Bosman explored the connection between an innate attachment system in children that needs to be nurtured, especially during times of distress. A key point to note in this theory is that once learned, it is a permanent fixture for a child. This theory is crucial to implement in the potential genesis of RAD in our opinion as not only does it incorporate the importance of positive and negative events in life that can modify the innate attachment system.
  • #30 Review of the Current Knowledge of Reactive Attachment Disorder – PMC Lock
    https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9736782/
    The current mediation hypothesis aims to discuss the relationship between a lack of emotional nurture and the development of RAD. […] The contrasting evidence concerning this hypothesis furthermore highlights the multifactorial quality of RAD. […] The attachment theory, described in an article published by Bosmans et al. in 2020 examined a correlation between attachment and security that a child may have with their caregiver and suggested that through an increase in attachment, a child may feel more secure and vice versa. […] In 2019, Kobak and Bosman explored the connection between an innate attachment system in children that needs to be nurtured, especially during times of distress. A key point to note in this theory is that once learned, it is a permanent fixture for a child. This theory is crucial to implement in the potential genesis of RAD in our opinion as not only does it incorporate the importance of positive and negative events in life that can modify the innate attachment system.
  • #31 Reactive attachment disorder symptoms and prosocial behavior in middle childhood: the role of Secure Base Script knowledge
    https://lirias.kuleuven.be/3283784
    Children with a reactive attachment disorder show inhibited and emotionally withdrawn behavior. Consequently, these children typically display prosocial behavior problems. However, the underlying mechanism between reactive attachment disorder and prosocial behavior problems is still unclear and findings in literature are mixed. […] Results did not support the mediation hypothesis, but evidence for the moderation hypothesis was found. Secure base script knowledge attenuated the negative association between attachment disorder symptoms and prosocial behavior. […] These findings contribute to the discussion about the link between attachment representations and attachment disorders.
  • #32 Reactive attachment disorder symptoms and prosocial behavior in middle childhood: the role of Secure Base Script knowledge | BMC Psychiatry | Full Text
    https://bmcpsychiatry.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12888-020-02931-3
    This raises the question whether attachment representations could play a different role than mediator in the link between RAD symptoms and prosocial behavior problems. […] The interaction effect suggested that children with more RAD symptoms and less SBS knowledge showed significantly more prosocial behavior problems than children with more RAD symptoms and more SBS knowledge.
  • #33 Reactive attachment disorder symptoms and prosocial behavior in middle childhood: the role of Secure Base Script knowledge | BMC Psychiatry | Full Text
    https://bmcpsychiatry.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12888-020-02931-3
    Children with a reactive attachment disorder show inhibited and emotionally withdrawn behavior. Consequently, these children typically display prosocial behavior problems. However, the underlying mechanism between reactive attachment disorder and prosocial behavior problems is still unclear and findings in literature are mixed. […] The current study focused on the role of attachment representations and tested whether these representations either mediate or moderate the link between RAD symptoms and prosocial behavior problems. […] The current mediation hypothesis follows psychiatric theory that assumes a unique link between RAD symptoms and insecure attachment. The attachment disorder terminology seems to suggest that insecure attachment representations, (i.c., lack of SBS knowledge) are the core and most specific issue when children show RAD symptoms.
  • #34 Reactive attachment disorder symptoms and prosocial behavior in middle childhood: the role of Secure Base Script knowledge | BMC Psychiatry | Full Text
    https://bmcpsychiatry.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12888-020-02931-3
    In all, theory predicts to find that all children with RAD symptoms display ruptured trust in the availability of their primary caregivers, mirrored in insecure attachment representations. In turn, attachment theory assumes that insecure attachment representations are linked with children’s decreased prosocial behavior. […] The second hypothesis proposes that attachment representations may play a moderating role in the link between RAD symptoms and prosocial behavior problems. […] The current study aimed to test the hypothesis that children high on RAD symptoms with more SBS knowledge show less decreased prosocial behavior than children high on RAD symptoms with less SBS knowledge. […] Although this mediation hypothesis aligns with ruling theory, research shows that it is surprisingly difficult to find evidence in favor of a robust association between measures of both constructs of RAD symptoms and attachment security.
  • #35 Reactive attachment disorder – Wikipedia
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_attachment_disorder
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is described in clinical literature as a severe disorder that can affect children, although these issues do occasionally persist into adulthood. […] RAD arises from a failure to form normal attachments to primary caregivers in early childhood. Such a failure could result from severe early experiences of neglect, abuse, abrupt separation from caregivers between the ages of six months and three years, frequent changes of caregivers, or a lack of caregiver responsiveness to a child’s communicative efforts. […] Children with RAD are presumed to have grossly disturbed internal working models of relationships that may lead to interpersonal and behavioral difficulties in later life. […] However, the opening of orphanages in Eastern Europe following the end of the Cold War in the early 1990s provided opportunities for research on infants and toddlers brought up in very deprived conditions. Such research broadened the understanding of the prevalence, causes, mechanism and assessment of disorders of attachment and led to efforts from the late 1990s onwards to develop treatment and prevention programs and better methods of assessment.
  • #36 Reactive Attachment Disorder
    http://www.personalityresearch.org/papers/wood.html
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is one of the few disorders listed in the DSM-IV that can be applied to infants. It is a disorder caused by a lack of attachment to any specific caregiver at an early age, and results in an inability for the child to form normal, loving relationships with others. […] Due to the relative newness of reactive attachment disorder as an accepted clinical diagnosis, there are a variety of criticisms of the current conceptualization of RAD. […] Also, pathogenic care is described as the etiology for RAD, with little attention given to a biological predisposition to developing the disorder. […] Although no research has been conducted on the influence of temperament on the development of RAD, current knowledge suggests that temperament may play an important role in the etiology of RAD, and its impact should be investigated further.
  • #37 Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) | EBSCO Research Starters
    https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/psychology/reactive-attachment-disorder-rad
    Foremost is the striking paucity of evidence for the validity of this diagnosis. […] Some developmental psychologists suggest that RAD is best conceptualized as a developmental disorder or a maltreatment syndrome. […] Moreover, findings in the child maltreatment literature suggest that although maltreated children often develop insecure or disorganized relational patterns to cope with the erratic care they receive, this is not necessarily synonymous with disordered attachment. […] A third area of controversy surrounding RAD is the emergence of unvalidated and potentially dangerous attachment therapies, which are sometimes used with disruptive children and adolescents believed to be traumatized by early adverse emotional experiences or adoption.
  • #38 Reactive Attachment Disorder: Concepts, Treatment, and Research
    https://kuscholarworks.ku.edu/entities/publication/7999dfd6-8f81-4e86-bd8b-c758499cdbe4
    Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) is a disorder characterized by controversy, both with respect to its definition and its treatment. By definition, the RAD diagnosis attempts to characterize and explain the origin of certain troubling behaviors in children. The RAD diagnosis presumes that „pathogenic care” of a young child can result in an array of markedly disturbed behaviors in social interactions and poor attachments to caregivers and others. […] Several authors question whether RAD is a valid diagnostic category, citing the overlap of symptoms with Pervasive Developmental Disorder and other disorders, the inconsistent connection to attachment theory, and the lack of empirical validation. […] The controversy about treatment of children with RAD centers on the practice of „holding therapy,” especially when the child is held against his/her will and struggles to resist. Although proponents argue that this experiential method is necessary for the child to establish a bond, or attachment, with a caregiver, critics decry that the experience can be traumatizing, and that any apparent behavioral gains could be the result of trauma bonds, not healthy attachment relations.
  • #39 Caring for Kids New to Canada – Attachment Disorders
    https://kidsnewtocanada.ca/mental-health/attachment-disorders
    Little information is available regarding RAD symptom stability. One study suggests that RAD symptoms stabilize between 22 and 54 months of age, and last longer in children who have been institutionalized for longer periods of time. […] Indiscriminate behaviours associated with this disorder tend to persist into adolescence. Overfriendliness and attention-seeking have been observed in formerly institutionalized children between 4 and 8 years of age. […] Attachment disorders often exist alongside other disorders associated with early deprivation. For RAD, these may include depression, problems in social relatedness, PTSD and cognitive and language delays. For DSED, co-morbid disorders may include problems in social relatedness, externalizing disorders (particularly ADHD), PTSD and cognitive and language delays. […] Attachment disorders are difficult to diagnose. Practice guidelines call for repeated observations of the child interacting with primary caregivers as well as a history of the child’s interactions with these caregivers.
  • #40 Caring for Kids New to Canada – Attachment Disorders
    https://kidsnewtocanada.ca/mental-health/attachment-disorders
    Little information is available regarding RAD symptom stability. One study suggests that RAD symptoms stabilize between 22 and 54 months of age, and last longer in children who have been institutionalized for longer periods of time. […] Indiscriminate behaviours associated with this disorder tend to persist into adolescence. Overfriendliness and attention-seeking have been observed in formerly institutionalized children between 4 and 8 years of age. […] Attachment disorders often exist alongside other disorders associated with early deprivation. For RAD, these may include depression, problems in social relatedness, PTSD and cognitive and language delays. For DSED, co-morbid disorders may include problems in social relatedness, externalizing disorders (particularly ADHD), PTSD and cognitive and language delays. […] Attachment disorders are difficult to diagnose. Practice guidelines call for repeated observations of the child interacting with primary caregivers as well as a history of the child’s interactions with these caregivers.
  • #41 Caring for Kids New to Canada – Attachment Disorders
    https://kidsnewtocanada.ca/mental-health/attachment-disorders
    Little information is available regarding RAD symptom stability. One study suggests that RAD symptoms stabilize between 22 and 54 months of age, and last longer in children who have been institutionalized for longer periods of time. […] Indiscriminate behaviours associated with this disorder tend to persist into adolescence. Overfriendliness and attention-seeking have been observed in formerly institutionalized children between 4 and 8 years of age. […] Attachment disorders often exist alongside other disorders associated with early deprivation. For RAD, these may include depression, problems in social relatedness, PTSD and cognitive and language delays. For DSED, co-morbid disorders may include problems in social relatedness, externalizing disorders (particularly ADHD), PTSD and cognitive and language delays. […] Attachment disorders are difficult to diagnose. Practice guidelines call for repeated observations of the child interacting with primary caregivers as well as a history of the child’s interactions with these caregivers.
  • #42 Reactive Attachment Disorder
    http://www.personalityresearch.org/papers/wood.html
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is one of the few disorders listed in the DSM-IV that can be applied to infants. It is a disorder caused by a lack of attachment to any specific caregiver at an early age, and results in an inability for the child to form normal, loving relationships with others. […] Due to the relative newness of reactive attachment disorder as an accepted clinical diagnosis, there are a variety of criticisms of the current conceptualization of RAD. […] Also, pathogenic care is described as the etiology for RAD, with little attention given to a biological predisposition to developing the disorder. […] Although no research has been conducted on the influence of temperament on the development of RAD, current knowledge suggests that temperament may play an important role in the etiology of RAD, and its impact should be investigated further.
  • #43 Module 4 -Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder and Reactive Attachment – Behavioral Disorders of Childhood
    https://opentext.wsu.edu/behavioral-disorders-childhood/chapter/module-4-disinhibited-social-engagement-disorder-and-reactive-attachment/
    Severe social neglect and impaired caregiving is the overall cause for both disinhibited social engagement disorder and reactive attachment disorder. […] These experiences disrupt the attachment process during the critical developmental period for a child. This disruption results in behavioral patterns that are problematic, not only in the short-term, but long-term, particularly if no interventions are implemented. […] Some evidence has been presented suggesting that both blunted reward sensitivity and decreased inhibitory control are associated with indiscriminate social behavior. Multiple placement disruptions, a mother with borderline personality disorder, aberrant caregiving behaviors, and low quality of care are also implicated as causes. […] It should be noted that the disorder may still persist even if the child’s caregiving environment greatly improves. […] Some genetic vulnerabilities involving the brain-derived neurotrophic factor and serotonin transporter genes, combined with history of neglect/caregiving, may result in more significant difficulties with social disinhibition.
  • #44 Caring for Kids New to Canada – Attachment Disorders
    https://kidsnewtocanada.ca/mental-health/attachment-disorders
    Reactive attachment disorder happens when no figure is found to attach to in early life. […] The essential elements of pathogenic care and their association with the onset and differentiation of disorder are not well understood. However, we know that pathogenic care is a necessary but insufficient condition for attachment disorder. Not all children who experience such conditions develop RAD or DSED; indeed, most do not. […] Environmental considerations and what differentiates low quality care from pathogenic care are always difficult to ascertain or study in very young children. However, known risk factors include: length of time in institutional care, adoption (in institution-reared children), parental maltreatment, having a mother who has been hospitalized for psychiatric reasons, or extremely disrupted mother/child communication (in home-reared children).
  • #45 Child Attachment Disorder: Causes and Treatment
    https://patient.info/doctor/child-attachment-disorder-pro
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) occurs in the context of grossly inadequate child care (eg, severe neglect, maltreatment, institutional deprivation) and is characterised by grossly abnormal attachment behaviours in early childhood. […] Evidence suggests that genetic factors do not play a role and attachment disorders arise primarily as a result of the care environment to which the child is exposed. […] Attachment disorders arise almost exclusively where there has been pathogenic care. Therefore, causes include: Child maltreatment, such as neglect or abuse. […] There may be an increased risk of contact with the youth justice system, although this is probably due to a number of factors rather than attachment issues alone. […] NICE guidelines of 2015 focus on early recognition of the potential for attachment disorder, and prevention or early management by improving the care environment.
  • #46 Reactive attachment disorder and disinhibited social engagement disorder in adolescence: co-occurring psychopathology and psychosocial problems | European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
    https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00787-020-01673-7
    A combined RAD and DSED is reported to frequently co-occur with both emotional symptoms and disorders (such as depression and anxiety) and behavioral symptoms and disorders (such as oppositional defiant disorder (ODD), conduct disorder (CD) or attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD)). […] Finding that both emotional and behavioral problems may co-occur with RAD and be associated with RAD symptom load in adolescence is concordant with previous findings among school-aged children and early adolescents. […] Although there is a possibility of type-II errors where observed differences are not statistically significant due to small sample sizes, the above studies of pre-schoolers used dimensional measures of psychopathology, thereby eliminating potential type-II errors due to reduced power by categorical measures.
  • #47 Reactive attachment disorder and disinhibited social engagement disorder in adolescence: co-occurring psychopathology and psychosocial problems | European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
    https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00787-020-01673-7
    A combined RAD and DSED is reported to frequently co-occur with both emotional symptoms and disorders (such as depression and anxiety) and behavioral symptoms and disorders (such as oppositional defiant disorder (ODD), conduct disorder (CD) or attention deficit hyperactive disorder (ADHD)). […] Finding that both emotional and behavioral problems may co-occur with RAD and be associated with RAD symptom load in adolescence is concordant with previous findings among school-aged children and early adolescents. […] Although there is a possibility of type-II errors where observed differences are not statistically significant due to small sample sizes, the above studies of pre-schoolers used dimensional measures of psychopathology, thereby eliminating potential type-II errors due to reduced power by categorical measures.
  • #48 Reactive attachment disorder and disinhibited social engagement disorder in adolescence: co-occurring psychopathology and psychosocial problems | European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
    https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00787-020-01673-7
    The prevalence rates of ADHD and CD/ODD in adolescents with DSED resemble findings in preschool and school-aged children with signs of DSED, including home-reared and post-institutionally adopted children. […] The overall finding that DSED in adolescence is associated with both emotional and behavioral problems is also in line with some results from studies of younger children.
  • #49 Reactive attachment disorder and disinhibited social engagement disorder in adolescence: co-occurring psychopathology and psychosocial problems | European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
    https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00787-020-01673-7
    The prevalence rates of ADHD and CD/ODD in adolescents with DSED resemble findings in preschool and school-aged children with signs of DSED, including home-reared and post-institutionally adopted children. […] The overall finding that DSED in adolescence is associated with both emotional and behavioral problems is also in line with some results from studies of younger children.
  • #50 Reactive Attachment Disorder | Treatment & Management | Point of Care
    https://www.statpearls.com/point-of-care/19406
    Experiments completed in the 1940s and 1950s found that maternal deprivation had a profound effect on infant growth, motor development, social interaction, and behavior. […] These early experiments became the foundation for Attachment Theory and outlined the constellation of symptoms of what the DSM, Third Edition (DSMIII) would later call reactive attachment disorder. […] Abuse in childhood has been correlated with difficulties in working memory and executive functioning, while severe neglect is associated with underdevelopment of the left cerebral hemisphere and the hippocampus. […] Social skills are below what would be expected of either their chronological age or developmental level. […] RAD increases the risk of anxiety, depression, hyperactivity, and reduces frustration tolerance.
  • #51 Caring for Kids New to Canada – Attachment Disorders
    https://kidsnewtocanada.ca/mental-health/attachment-disorders
    Little information is available regarding RAD symptom stability. One study suggests that RAD symptoms stabilize between 22 and 54 months of age, and last longer in children who have been institutionalized for longer periods of time. […] Indiscriminate behaviours associated with this disorder tend to persist into adolescence. Overfriendliness and attention-seeking have been observed in formerly institutionalized children between 4 and 8 years of age. […] Attachment disorders often exist alongside other disorders associated with early deprivation. For RAD, these may include depression, problems in social relatedness, PTSD and cognitive and language delays. For DSED, co-morbid disorders may include problems in social relatedness, externalizing disorders (particularly ADHD), PTSD and cognitive and language delays. […] Attachment disorders are difficult to diagnose. Practice guidelines call for repeated observations of the child interacting with primary caregivers as well as a history of the child’s interactions with these caregivers.
  • #52 Part I- Behind the mask of Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) – Smarter Parenting
    https://www.smarterparenting.com/part-i-behind-the-mask-of-reactive-attachment-disorder-rad/
    Reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is a complicated mental health disorder that is fairly uncommon among the general public, yet very common among children who have had inconsistent primary caregivers. […] RAD develops in young children who have limited emotional attachments to others and is found on a large continuum, ranging from very mild attachment problems to severe cases of extreme sociopathic behavior. […] Recent research suggests that noticeable attachment problems have been identified in children as early as their first birthday. […] Experts suggest that trauma develops in institutionalized children when they are separated from their birth mothers. […] This inconsistent and disingenuous relationship with adults creates distrust and forces the infant to begin self-regulating on their own.
  • #53 Reactive Attachment Disorder: Symptoms and Causes | BetterHelp
    https://www.betterhelp.com/mental-health/disorders-conditions/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    The American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry notes that because children who experience such neglect are not given the chance to form attachments to caregivers in their early development, they have learned not to seek any comfort or response from caregivers. […] Note that not every child who experiences social neglect develops mental disorders like reactive attachment disorder (RAD), a stressor-related condition of early childhood caused by social neglect and by markedly disturbed and developmentally inappropriate ways of relating to others. […] A majority of children raised in these conditions do not, as reactive attachment disorder (RAD) is a rare disorder, like other attachment disorders, such as disinhibited social engagement disorder (DSED). […] Because RAD is rooted in traumatic experiences, the most effective therapeutic techniques to treat this disorder and its signs and symptoms are often those that are trauma-informed and understand the role a primary caregiver can have in supporting a young child. […] Reactive attachment disorder is a trauma- and stressor-based disorder, before any treatment can be effective, it may be helpful for the individual to be in a situation where the trauma is not recurring.
  • #54 Disorders Specifically Associated with Stress: Reactive Attachment Disorder and Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder | SpringerLink
    https://link.springer.com/10.1007/978-3-030-51366-5_25
    Two disorders defined as reaction to early experiences of social neglect are reactive attachment disorder (RAD) and disinhibited social engagement disorder (DSED). […] Reactive attachment disorder is characterized by emotionally inhibited and socially unresponsive behaviors. Its features are characteristic of young children who lack a preferred attachment figure, despite having the cognitive capacity to form attachments. […] Although signs of reactive attachment disorder typically resolve when children are removed from deprived environments, less clear is whether RAD in early childhood predisposes the child to subsequent interpersonal difficulties even after the disorder is no longer detectable. […] There is preliminary evidence that signs of DSED in early childhood are associated with decreased competence in early adolescence, even if signs of the disorder are no longer present.
  • #55 Management of a Child with Reactive Attachment Disorder in the Dental Clinical Setting: A Case Report
    http://www.scielo.sa.cr/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S2215-34112020000100039
    RAD usually begins before the age of 5 years and persists over time. […] It results from a lack of basic emotional attachment and/or pathogenic care conditions, particularly during the first years of childhood. […] The disorder has also been strongly associated with early maltreatment and affects deprivation by the primary caregiver, typically through abuse, neglect, and abandonment. […] In RAD children, psychological depression leads to increased levels of cortisol, inefficiencies in the functioning of serotonin and other neurotransmitters and reduced growth-hormone production. […] The medical management of the disorder is fundamentally psychological (e.g. enhanced caregiving, promoting secure and healthy attachments, teaching of basic pragmatic skills to affected children, developing appropriate rules and realistic limits, and maintaining routines for increasing feelings of security, in a consistent and compassionate manner), and, in some cases, psychiatric with specific drugs.
  • #56 Management of a Child with Reactive Attachment Disorder in the Dental Clinical Setting: A Case Report
    http://www.scielo.sa.cr/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S2215-34112020000100039
    It has been reported that the lack of treatment for RAD during childhood may be associated with adults who are diagnosed with sociopathic, narcissistic, antisocial or borderline disorders. […] Thus, the early recognition of the disorder, etiologic or precipitating factors, management, and effective parenting guiding are reasonable knowledge expectations for all healthcare providers, including pediatric dentistry practitioners. […] The pediatric dentistry practitioner should approach the affected children according to their individual behavioral health care and communication needs and bearing in mind the inability of these patients to respond adequately to the affection and diverse social situations.
  • #57 Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) – CTRLCare Behavioral Health
    https://ctrlcarebh.com/what-we-treat/mental-health/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    RAD is a serious condition that affects children who have experienced early childhood neglect, abuse, or inconsistent caregiving, which prevents them from developing healthy emotional bonds. […] These challenges can persist into adulthood if not treated properly. […] Excessive technology use can also displace healthier activities like building face-to-face relationships or developing interpersonal skills. Over time, this reliance can hinder emotional growth and worsen symptoms of RAD. […] While technology use itself doesn’t cause RAD, excessive use can exacerbate attachment-related issues and make it more difficult to establish solid connections. […] Yes, while RAD is typically diagnosed in children, its effects can last into adulthood, leading to challenges in forming healthy relationships and managing emotions.
  • #58 Spotting and Treating Reactive Attachment Disorder – Lido Wellness Center | Trauma and Mental Health Center Newport Beach
    https://lidowellnesscenter.com/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    Reactive Attachment Disorder occurs in children who have not formed a healthy emotional attachment to their primary caregivers during their early years. It could be a result of neglect, abuse, or frequent changes in caregivers. Whatever the reason the bonds are not created between the child and their parents (or caregivers). […] RAD does not occur intentionally on the child’s part. It’s not like the child is intentionally getting revenge or feeling like they are wronged, its more about understanding that when a child’s basic needs for comfort, affection, and nurturing aren’t met, they learn to protect themselves by distancing from others. […] Though RAD is not typically diagnosed in adults, many of the maladaptive behaviors and feelings can persist and present as other types of relational or personality disorders.
  • #59 Spotting and Treating Reactive Attachment Disorder – Lido Wellness Center | Trauma and Mental Health Center Newport Beach
    https://lidowellnesscenter.com/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    A fundamental lack of trust in others can continue into adulthood. They might be continually suspicious of others’ intentions, making it hard for them to form stable relationships. […] Unresolved feelings from childhood can manifest as anger and aggression or a need to control situations and people around them. […] Adults who had RAD as children may also be more susceptible to conditions like depression, anxiety disorders, or personality disorders.
  • #60 Spotting and Treating Reactive Attachment Disorder – Lido Wellness Center | Trauma and Mental Health Center Newport Beach
    https://lidowellnesscenter.com/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    A fundamental lack of trust in others can continue into adulthood. They might be continually suspicious of others’ intentions, making it hard for them to form stable relationships. […] Unresolved feelings from childhood can manifest as anger and aggression or a need to control situations and people around them. […] Adults who had RAD as children may also be more susceptible to conditions like depression, anxiety disorders, or personality disorders.
  • #61 Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) & Substance Use | Dual Diagnosis
    https://www.burningtree.com/dual-diagnosis/trauma-stress-disorders/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    The correlation between Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) in childhood and substance abuse patterns in adulthood can be understood through the lens of attachment theory and the long-term impact of early relational trauma. […] Children with RAD often struggle with forming secure attachments due to early neglect or inconsistent caregiving. As these children grow into adults, the lack of secure attachment can affect their coping mechanisms, leading them to seek comfort or escape from emotional distress in maladaptive ways, including substance abuse. […] One of the hallmarks of RAD is difficulty in regulating emotions, stemming from early attachment issues. […] Adults who experienced RAD in childhood are at a higher risk for a variety of mental health issues, including anxiety, depression, and personality disorders.
  • #62 Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) & Substance Use | Dual Diagnosis
    https://www.burningtree.com/dual-diagnosis/trauma-stress-disorders/reactive-attachment-disorder/
    The correlation between Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) in childhood and substance abuse patterns in adulthood can be understood through the lens of attachment theory and the long-term impact of early relational trauma. […] Children with RAD often struggle with forming secure attachments due to early neglect or inconsistent caregiving. As these children grow into adults, the lack of secure attachment can affect their coping mechanisms, leading them to seek comfort or escape from emotional distress in maladaptive ways, including substance abuse. […] One of the hallmarks of RAD is difficulty in regulating emotions, stemming from early attachment issues. […] Adults who experienced RAD in childhood are at a higher risk for a variety of mental health issues, including anxiety, depression, and personality disorders.